Weighing ingredients

2,236
695
Joined Oct 31, 2012
     I happen to own a commercial bakers balance scale. As I won't be using it, I have tried to get it in the hands of a couple of local professional bakers who own their own successful shops.  The two who responded so far told me they don't need them because they don't weigh anything. I am still waiting to hear from the third one. 

     I expected to be told that they used a modern digital scale so an old fashioned balance scale would be out of date but to be told they don't weigh any ingredients really surprised me. Is this common?  Are they pulling my leg? 
 
535
88
Joined Oct 11, 2014
OMGoodness I would LOVE that scale!! 

It is a sad reality that most commercial bakeries do not weigh anything as they no longer do anything from scratch. If they are baking from scratch then they have been poorly trained and that is a shame. The odds of their products not being consistent is a huge one. So I think they might be pulling your chain?? /img/vbsmilies/smilies/biggrin.gif
 
535
88
Joined Oct 11, 2014
It is because they buy the manufactured frozen par-baked stuff so all they need is some baking trays, parchment and an oven or even dumbed down to a Merry Chef oven. No measurements required. It breaks my heart to see this.
 
87
10
Joined Apr 12, 2016
 
It is because they buy the manufactured frozen par-baked stuff so all they need is some baking trays, parchment and an oven or even dumbed down to a Merry Chef oven. No measurements required. It breaks my heart to see this.
Can that even be considered baking???  My 10 year old nephew can warm things up too?

WTF?
 
Last edited:
535
88
Joined Oct 11, 2014
Yup  the exact same words right outta me mouth when I first learned of this.. That is why when they start talking about cost cutting and buying in desserts from frozen or manufactured baking companies I tend to bite my tongue until it bleeds. I despise that type of thinking in the food industry period. This is one of the main reasons why we struggle so hard in the industry the way we do to make it is because of this behaviour........however, it is understood as to why people do it so we can't really ask them not to. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/wink.gif
 
2,236
695
Joined Oct 31, 2012
      Actually, both places/owners I've talked to thus far actually do baking from scratch. I've had their products and watched them work.

I was busy chatting so never thought to observe the measuring. I just assumed they were. Never asked until today when I let them know I had the balance scale. 

      The third one I haven't heard from yet specializes, near as I can tell, in fancy cakes and I got a look around the kitchen today while offering the scale. There were ovens, a big floor mixer, table, and all the rest but no scale I could see. 

     So from what I've learned so far, at least for the first two, it's from scratch baking but simply tossing a bit of this and a bit of that together. They were quite serious about not measuring. I posted this experience to see how wide spread it is because that's not the way I was taught baking was supposed to happen in a professional setting, not even for cookies. 
 
Last edited:
87
10
Joined Apr 12, 2016
 
      Actually, both places/owners I've talked to thus far actually do baking from scratch. I've had their products and watched them work.

I was busy chatting so never thought to observe the measuring. I just assumed they were. Never asked until today when I let them know I had the balance scale. 

      The third one I haven't heard from yet specializes, near as I can tell, in fancy cakes and I got a look around the kitchen today while offering the scale. There were ovens, a big floor mixer, table, and all the rest but no scale I could see. 

     So from what I've learned so far, at least for the first two, it's from scratch baking but simply tossing a bit of this and a bit of that together. They were quite serious about not measuring. I posted this experience to see how wide spread it is because that's not the way I was taught baking was supposed to happen in a professional setting, not even for cookies. 
So how do they keep track of consistency.  I get it their pros at what they do and its probably all in their head, but even for my little restaurant, we measure spices to put in the rice to stay consistent.  Same with the garlic sauce, same with the Humus dip......
 
535
88
Joined Oct 11, 2014
Yea, I would definitely have to see what it is that they are doing because if it is truly by scratch then they HAVE to measure. So they might have a scale on the mixer or somewhere they place out of the way for measuring ingredients. I would ask them to see the whole process from start to finish with what they are baking. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/biggrin.gif
 
87
10
Joined Apr 12, 2016
 
Yea, I would definitely have to see what it is that they are doing because if it is truly by scratch then they HAVE to measure. So they might have a scale on the mixer or somewhere they place out of the way for measuring ingredients. I would ask them to see the whole process from start to finish with what they are baking. /img/vbsmilies/smilies/biggrin.gif
I'd Love to be a fly on the wall during that conversation.  Get booted out like Jazz on Fresh Prince /img/vbsmilies/smilies/biggrin.gif  
 
Last edited:
535
88
Joined Oct 11, 2014
Lol, yea.....I am one of those people that will call a person out on their bulls#*t if they try to sell me on it. It smells pretty ripe if these guys are doing everything by scratch and not weighing their ingredients. They might be measuring it by volume instead of weight which, unless it is liquid, is not a good thing and creates inconsistencies in product. I am curious tho.....it has piqued my interest....however @chefwriter  don't go and get yourself in trouble with the bakers....lol!!
 
87
10
Joined Apr 12, 2016
 
Lol, yea.....I am one of those people that will call a person out on their bulls#*t if they try to sell me on it. It smells pretty ripe if these guys are doing everything by scratch and not weighing their ingredients. They might be measuring it by volume instead of weight which, unless it is liquid, is not a good thing and creates inconsistencies in product. I am curious tho.....it has piqued my interest....however @chefwriter  don't go and get yourself in trouble with the bakers....lol!!
Can't help but think of that scene in Fargo with the woodchipper, but in this case it would be a meat grinder or a mixer........DON'T GET THE BAKER ANGRY/img/vbsmilies/smilies/eek.gif
 
5,192
296
Joined Jul 28, 2001
Most bakeries basically offer the same products. The only difference is that the successful ones practice customer service and consistency. My scaler has been with me for 18 yrs. I still make him use the sheet protector over the formula and check it off with erasable markers he goes.

You can't stay in business with a little of this and a little of that. That's absurd!   After 20 yrs. our customers can tell someone, Oh I'm bringing this great cake. If it is not exactly like it was 20 yrs. ago

you won't see them again. Consistency in a bakery is when the customer tells you," please make sure you put your label on the box so they know where it's coming from".

If a bakery is doing just cakes and cookies, it's possible they might use a digital or table top scale. If they are baking bread and don't have a balance scale, I promiss you, their freezer is larger than all refrigeration put together.

We use our freezer as a tool for production. Not for storage.

Only some, usually larger food establishments, can survive on consistency alone. Mickey D's. Although the cashiers and order takers have sort of a robotic consistency.

I have walked into small bakeries to spend a week consulting. If I see someone measuring with a gallon container or cups, I will usually express that when they convert all

of their formulas to weight I'll be back. Still leave the 600. invoice for the day. They bitch, I tell them the charge is very inexpensive compared to the quality and increased sales.
 
3,292
726
Joined May 5, 2010
No one has mentioned this as yet, I think, but not weighing ingredients could simply mean that the bakers already know from many years experience that 1 bag of mix to so much yeast and water will produce the dough they need.

Even taking this a bit further in that this same experience can leave you with the ability to throw ingredients together scratch-wise and have the product come out fine.
 
5,541
978
Joined Oct 10, 2005
Not in my experience. Eggs, for instance weigh anywhere from 50 gr ea. to almost 75gr, multiply this by 10or15 and your recipie is waaaay out of whack. Butter NEEDS to be scaled out, especially when you buy it in bulk 25kg cubes, you can't eyeball a hunkk and say it weighs 680gr.

For bread, yeah, you may be right, a sack of flour, this much yeast, that much salt, and liquid measure of water.

How on earth do you do inventory without a scale?

A confession though. I hate beam/balance scales. Complicated with all those loose weights and it takes forever to scale out compared to an electronic one, keep them in museums or at home, but I have no time for those things
 
5,192
296
Joined Jul 28, 2001
@Chefross  , that's true, especially for bread, but a balance is necessary to scale the dough. Both for consistency and uniformity but also for cooking times. 1# 2oz loaf is not going to be

done if the majority are 1#
 
5,192
296
Joined Jul 28, 2001
@foodpump  ,
A confession though. I hate beam/balance scales. Complicated with all those loose weights and it takes forever to scale out compared to an electronic one, keep them in museums or at home, but I have no time for those things
I agree with that, and we now use a platform scale more than before. But for scaling bread, there's nothing equivalent to the balance. We don't own a beam scale.
 
Last edited:
3,292
726
Joined May 5, 2010
 
@Chefross  , that's true, especially for bread, but a balance is necessary to scale the dough. Both for consistency and uniformity but also for cooking times. 1# 2oz loaf is not going to be

done if the majority are 1#
True dat.....I forgot about scaling the dough....Me bad.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom