Thin blades vs. stiff

Discussion in 'Cooking Knife Reviews' started by lisas ktchen, Feb 18, 2015.

  1. lisas ktchen

    lisas ktchen

    Likes Received:
    Professional Caterer
    My research leaves me confused. My Henckel 10" chef's knife has been my workhorse for almost 30 years. I cook at my gourmet B&B and prior to that cooked in professional kitchens for about 12 years, which is when I bought my Henckels. The tip just broke off my chef's knife and I'm looking to replace it. I understand the Henckels are no longer the best and looking at the Messermeister Meridian Elite or the Victorinox. While I like the sharpness of a thinner blade, I'm concerned it could chip (read that somewhere) and afraid I'll miss the weight of my Henckel. Also looking for a knife that will keep a good edge. Not looking to spend $200 or more, but want a knife I'll be happy with for a long time. I'd appreciate any and all suggestions.
  2. benuser


    Likes Received:
    Home Cook
    First: have the broken tip repaired. Depending on the damage the blade will certainly become a bit shorter, but you still will have a usable knife.
    You're a used to a tough, soft stainless. Victorinox, Henckels-Zwilling, Burgvogel-Messermeister, Wüsthof, all use the same steel by Krupp. We aren't going to change that. It's almost impossible to have it chip: it will roll, fold, whatever you imagine, but never chip. Hard steel may chip, German soft stainless never will.
    You're used to a neutral or handle heavy balance. Rock-chopping alot I guess.
    Have a new Wüsthof or Zwilling. A thin Victorinox will feel much lighter than you're used to.
  3. rick alan

    rick alan

    Likes Received:
    Cook At Home
    This knife would be similar to the Vic in weight, but I think I real revelation to you in terms of their cutting ability, and the price is not too far out.  Coming from Jon it will have a beautifully convexed grind for good food release (food sticks to a Vic like a suction cup) and also will be thin at the edge.  Significantly better edge retention but it won't chip.  The handle is infinitely more comfortable than a Vic, unless you power-sand it to a better shape.  A lot more than a Vic but also a lot of knife for the money.  Looks like it will even rock-chop a bit.  It is also a significant step up from the Fujiwara which gets a lot of recommendation for value around $100.

    You may like a MAC Pro even better as it's heavier, but then you're well over $200.

    Last edited: Feb 19, 2015