Petrozza got robbed

1,414
17
Joined Mar 12, 2005
Petrozza got robbed.

Christina picked the easy safe menu, and still didn't check the food going out and had food coming back, to me that would be unacceptable.
 
1,593
44
Joined Jun 27, 2006
The DW (and I...... very quietly) were pulling for Petrozza. Sadly I think that age, gender and looks did him in. As it's been suggested on another thread on this subject........Sex or Sexy sells. Personally I didn't see it but ol' Chef Gordon Ramsay sure did. :rolleyes::look: Actually she may have the best opportunity for future because she's so young. I say that knowing Petrozza's my age but that doesn't mean we're dead yet. Unfortunately that's not the way many see it. Nowadays 50 may be the new 40 but not when it comes to Career:roll: I think I said that right:smiles:
 
25
10
Joined Mar 15, 2008
i would so rather work for Petrozza but oh well Ramsey picked Christina beacuse shes young and they can mold her up to what they want i guess???? and shes a cute little thing.
 

phatch

Moderator
Staff member
8,933
722
Joined Mar 29, 2002
Based on how few of the past winners have really followed through with the prize, i figure he picked the "winner" he could get rid of the fastest and move on with his restaurant.

Phil
 
1,414
17
Joined Mar 12, 2005
What do you mean "get rid of" They showed them meeting with Rock on the show at the restaurant he was running, plus last year they met with the girl that won the year before that at the restaurant she was running, so he must still be running his retaurant. Do you think the other winners only work the restaurant for a little while and then are let go?

Plus to be on the show they probably have to sign something saying they are available to relocate to run the restaurant if they win.
 
89
10
Joined Feb 22, 2006
Petrozza didn't have a much command of his crew as she had. It was portrayed that Petrozza didn't have all his **** together for prep....which led to his crew running out of food during service, big no no. His menu was beyond what his crew, and himself were capable of doing during that service.......hence his food sitting at the pass while he floundered.

That being said I was no fan of hers and whether is was him or her BOTH were just going to be puppets and media whores anyway. Besides, I'm ten million times better than what Jen "thinks" she is. ;)
 
1,414
17
Joined Mar 12, 2005
Yep, I don't think I'd give either one a job as head chef, especially not for $250k.

What I am wondering it why Petrozza didn't get more ingredients, such as the blue cheese from the pantry they have their. Plus he had 3 appetizers, and ran out of 2, so maybe no one order the 3rd and thats why he ran out.

I liked Petrozza's menu selections better, plus he won the last, and most important individual challange. Chirstina, and her 3 white castle type hamburgers for an appetizer, please.
 
89
10
Joined Feb 22, 2006
The only thing I can think of with the cheese is he broke under the pressure. I liked his menu....but like I said, I feel it was too much for that service and it played a part in the decision making process for Ramsay.

Sliders, aka white castle type burgers, are huge right now. In fact Julys ACF edition of the Culinary Review had a whole article on them. Keeping up with the trends.
 
302
10
Joined Apr 23, 2006
Yeah i thought for sure that when those 2 dishes came back because the butter wasnt melting that was the end of her.

Petrozza deff would have been a safe bet but at the end Gordon said he was thinking long term, and if thats true he made the right choice.

Petrozza knows how to cook, Christina knows that plus kitchen smarts and how to run people, he never bossed anyone till the end.
 
8
10
Joined May 17, 2008
Petrozza was absolutely robbed; that made me so upset! I figure that its more of a curse to win than to lose, so hopefully Louis will do better by himself, and Christina can flounder at the London West Hollywood so Chef Ramsey can just quietly remove her when the cameras are off... :smokin
 
1,414
17
Joined Mar 12, 2005
If your thinking long term, you hire Petrozza, and then tell Christina to come and apply in a few years when she has more experience. Restaurants aren't around for the long term if you can't make it in the short term.

Its unlikey someone with that amount of experience could acquire a job that pays that much in this industry by then.
 
89
10
Joined Feb 22, 2006
If you have ever watched the BBC version of Kitchen Nightmares, Ramsay usually props up the quiet, young cook in the background that has the passion but is just waiting in the wings. This is typical Ramsay M.O. Not to mention but most of his Chefs have been with him for a long long time. The man has a huge culinary empire with many people working for him. I;m sure he has a good sense of what is best for his business as well as a good sense of peoples potential. Petrozza right now for London L.A. may be a good fit in most peoples minds, but we all know he has more restaurants in the works and Christina will have more longevity than Petrozza.
 

kuan

Moderator
Staff member
6,932
450
Joined Jun 11, 2001
The winners never stay at any of Gordon's places anyway, so good for Petrozza actually. He'll track his career the proper way and gain some good experience along the way.

He needs to stop smoking though. :)
 
1,593
44
Joined Jun 27, 2006
In the end Christina did appear to have some talent and in all honesty I see the thought process of her age and the ability to mould her into what Chef Ramsay needed. Petrozza may have not bossed anyone but he did provide the teamwork and positive role model that seemed to be lacking in so many of the other contestants. He never seemed to "play the game" As the show unfolded you could see this in the background.

For what ever it's worth, the person running the station is responsible for the prep and stock of the prep on the station. Petrozza should have been more organized but we've all gotten lost in a moment once or twice. Jenn's comment of not her problem didn't set well with me but then she never did as a whole. She reminded me of three of my former Sous and very sore spots in my career. (They all graduated from Back Stab U) Her asking for a reference was hilarious. Sharp but still hilarious.

The whole show is nothing but editing wizardry and we've certainly recognized that. How can anyone really determine how talented the contestants really are or what point things were said and done and if they even followed the true chronological order of happening. I'd bet that different days are combined to create one episode. Then the comments Matt made were edited in such a way they first showed him telliing Chef Ramsay to shut the ***** up and then it was Christina. I gotta wonder if they (the Producers, writers and Staff) ever take a look at these boards and then just make things happen so we have something to kepp talking about. Maybe not but it's sure plausable.

I gotta say that because of the editing it does make it more enjoyable for the average viewer but I don't personally prefer that method. Then again I'm not the one in charge of the show so.......

All in all I don't believe Petrozza is going to suffer. It was some exposure and be it good or bad he will reap some benefits. Even the biggest of hack is gonna get something out of it whether it's the experience or possible more.
 
1,593
44
Joined Jun 27, 2006
I couldn't agree more. Never understood (being a life long nonsmoker) how it doesn't affect one's palette and sense of smell causing things to taste not as good as they could. NO! Not starting a whole pro/con for smoking just a simple professional observation.
 
302
10
Joined Apr 23, 2006
however that would be an interesting conversation to start up............:roll:


I cant help but to think how long they actualy stay in his restaurants. I mean this is what the 4th season or whatever? So when he brought in the exect chefs of his other restaurants, why werent any of them the other winers from the past years? Im sure they sign a contract saying if I win Im fully aware that I can be terminated within a certin date. Like im sure they sign a contract saying Ill work x amount of weeks before I can be fired and replaced with a trained, expereinced chef thats been all around the world, rather then streight from minnasota or whatever.
 

phatch

Moderator
Staff member
8,933
722
Joined Mar 29, 2002
Some of the early winners didn't take the prize at all. Too many strings attached, too restrictive. I only watched one season and the girl who won took a LONG time to decide to accept the prize (work in vegas as basically the sous chef). Early reports were that she was going to decline it outright.

Some other winners didn't last in their positions.

I really don't think the people on the show have the capability to do what needs to be done at the level Ramsay requires as a career.
 
1,593
44
Joined Jun 27, 2006
phatch, I thought this to be only season 4.

First season the winner was Michael Wray and he accepted an offer to work with Ramsay in London, but later chose not to go because of "family issues"

Second season the winner was Heather West and she was named senior chef of Terra Rossa at the Red Rock Resort Spa and Casino. Her contract has currently expired and she is now a chef at the Broadway Grill in Seattle, Washington. Sounds like she traded up and made a good career decision.

Third season the winner was Rock Harper and he was named head chef of Green Valley Ranch's Terra Verde. Currently, he is no longer a day-to-day chef with the restaurant, and is instead handling public relations for Terra Verde and the Green Valley Ranch Resort. Judging from how he spoke to this years contestants he seemed to be well in control of his career and even though he's not the Chef, it sounds like he made a positive career choice as well. :chef:
 
Top Bottom