Need 4 qt saucepan

4,381
89
Joined Aug 4, 2000
My 12 year old Adcraft 4 qt saucepan developed a leak indirectly due to burnt food and I need a replacement. The quality I need is just that, Adcraft, and neither Mauviel nor All-Clad. Yet, I seem to be having much difficulty finding a replacement. Any good sites that you list would be greatly appreciated.
 
8,550
207
Joined Feb 13, 2008
Darn! I hate it when a well-loved piece of cookware goes to the great stove in the sky. Even if it wasn't a such a much pan to begin with you get fond of them. For instance, I've got an aluminum 12" chicken fryer and an aluminum Windsor pan I got from Smart and Final which, in the greater scheme of pots and pans, are cheap Chinese junk. But they sure work for me.

Your Adcraft: Aluminum? Stainless with a sintered aluminum disk on the bottom?

Either way, there's nothing remarkable about Adcraft. As you said, it's neither Mauviel nor All-Clad. It's mid-grade pro cookware, and fairly fungible, and you should be able to find something suitable at any decent restaurant supply.

And really, there's nothing wrong with similar home cook stuff. "On sale" works just fine, and "deep discount" is even better.

That said, googling the search terms "adcraft cookware," got pages of hits. The first few I looked at it didn't have what I guess is the exact pan in question; but then I don't what the exact pan in question is either.

My best advice is that if you can't find it without too much trouble, get something else. Personally I tend to gravitate towards Vollrath and Lincoln, but there's nothing special about their mid level stuff either. Alla time same same.

BDL
 
1,691
38
Joined Dec 23, 2000
By happy chance, the just-published Cook's Illustrated has a review of 4-qt saucepans. The $195 AllClad came out on top, as usual.

The very close runner-up was the Cuisinart MultiClad at $70. CI's considered opinion was: buy the Cuisinart and put the left-over $125 in your piggy bank. :peace:

The priciest pots, $200 Viking, $275 Demeyere, and the $385 Mauviel all rated "not recommended" for their performance characteristics, and not just for the sky-high price.

Mike :laser:
 
5
10
Joined Feb 13, 2010
MikeLM;296407 said:
By happy chance, the just-published Cook's Illustrated has a review of 4-qt saucepans. The $195 AllClad came out on top, as usual.


I've been buying my All Clad at TJ Maxx and Home Goods for half price or less in some cases. They may be a little marked up, but they cook the same. I've had them for a little while and they are nothing less than amazing to me.

I bought a 4 qt All Clad Copper Core Sauce Pan w/lid for $129.00 last week.

Dan
 
4,381
89
Joined Aug 4, 2000
An update:

After a few weeks of use, I've decided to give the 4 qt Cuisinart pan to a friend of mine because of the narrow handle.  Although extremely well constructed, the Cuisinart pan offeres very little stability once held in the hand and food could conceivably be accidentally dumped out should an unexpected tilt occur.  And instead I opted for the 4 1/2 qt (note 4 1/2 qt) saucepan made by Winco.; it's handle offers a much larger diameter and feels much more stable in my hand and the overall pan is equally well-made.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom