Gyuto upgrade

Discussion in 'Cooking Knife Reviews' started by tino tavli, Mar 3, 2016.

  1. tino tavli

    tino tavli

    Likes Received:
    Professional Chef
    I've been a chef for quite a few years and although I don't put on a heavy amount of knife work in daily,I still put in a decent amount of prep 3-4 days/week.I was groomed on wustoffs in my early years, I owned a kikuichi which was stolen, and in the past 4 years I've been using a shun edit that was gifted to me. The edo is ok but klunky. I've gotten used to the weight and enormous handle but it's not a great performer and the size of the handle along with the weight gets a bit taxing. I'm not very familiar with all of the new steels available do this is why I'm asking. I would like a solid performer that I don't have to replace. Not too light and whippy, no gap between blade and handle like traditional Japanese knives. A 240 mm gyuto that will hold an edge but isn't a pain to sharpen. New steels are fine, budget up to $300
  2. ordo


    Likes Received:
    Home Cook
  3. foody518


    Likes Received:
    I Just Like Food
    Also possibly Gesshin Kagero.
    Or Misono Sweden if you are okay with full carbon/non stainless knife.
  4. rick alan

    rick alan

    Likes Received:
    Cook At Home
    Welcome to cheftalk TT.

    After taking a vacation from shun bashing I've gone back to it because it is for a fact a miserable slimy entity.  But as they say in the used car business, "Every horse has a buyer," so you should be able to find a colleague who thinks Edo's are the Cat's Ass, and will buy it from you.

    As a prep knife I can't say enough good about the Geshi Kagero.  The gyuto has a nice large flat spot, the high-tec SRS-15 PM steel takes a great edge for stainless and holds it forever.  And very easy to sharpen, being not excessively abrasion resistant on the stones, and burr removal a real breeze.  It is also very affordable.  For PM steel I'd pick it over everything else in the price range and category.  The Kohetsu HAP40 may get a little sharper and possibly have even better edge retention (no definitive answers here though), but I think all around the Kagero would be a better performer from comparisons I've heard.

    Last edited: Mar 6, 2016