Does Size Matter?

1
10
Joined Jun 21, 2011
I was in the market for a new Chef's knife.  Right now Im used to a 9".  After reading reviews I learned Shun Is very popular.  I bought a 10" classic shun and it's feeling a little big to me.  After using the 9" in school the shun 8" seems to small.  The problem is shun doesnt make a 9". Should I get used to the 10"? I hear it's a power house for prep in commercial kitchens. But are these big burley men saying this? Im a little woman...5'3 110lb.  It there an advantage for the extra inch?? 

Thanks!!!
 

phatch

Moderator
Staff member
8,885
692
Joined Mar 29, 2002
The bigger knife does offer some production advantages. I think you'll get used to it. I switch between an 8 and a 10 a lot. The 8 is the higher quality steel in my case and the 10 a good Henkels. The 10 is easier to do mirepoix with by size if I keep it as sharp as the 8. And the bigger knife is better for squash, watermelon and other larger prep tasks for sure.

Phil
 
1,896
571
Joined Jan 8, 2010
Sure: Size does matter ! (someone had to say it)...

I'm only slightly taller than you (and unfortunately a bit heavier as well /img/vbsmilies/smilies/frown.gif)

I started of by using 21 cm (8") chef knive's and have recently bought a 24 cm (9.5"). It looked impressive at first but proved very easy to handle. Maybe also because the 24 cm knife is about the same weight as the 21 cm one.

I also have a 27 cm (10.5") Victorinox knife lying around, but even though I can cope with it, I find it too big, but I bring it out when I need to carve a big roast (like whole lamb or pig). This knife is also a lot heavier than the others I own and I think that has quite a lot to do with it.

Note that my knives are used for home-cooking, so they don't see the amount of work a professional chef's knife does.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom