Best brand of active dry or instant yeast?

415
10
Joined Jan 15, 2001
Wanted to ask the serious bread bakers if there is a difference in performance among the brands. Which one would you recommend best?

Thanks.
 
2,550
13
Joined Mar 13, 2001
Personally, I haven't noticed any difference of performance between brands.

You may note differences between dry active, instant and fresh however. This should be an interesting thread!
 
1,403
37
Joined Jan 1, 2001
I like to use SAF instant yeast. It 's very reliable as long as you keep it airtight in the freezer and don't try to use it past the espiration date. I also like that you just mix it into your dry ingredients, add warm wet ingredients and boom, you have dough!
 

isa

3,236
11
Joined Apr 4, 2000
I'm surprised you keep your yeast in the freezer FF, I recall a discussion a few months ago when I was having yeast problems I was advice not to keep it in the fridge despite the fact that many books recommand the practice.
 
131
10
Joined Mar 12, 2001
I like Fermipan, but also use SAF instant and a new yeast that King arthur has out for sweet dough.

I keep all of my yeast, once it is opened, in the freezer in sealed glass jars. Yeast that is kept non refridgerated/frozen will lose it's potency I have found, over time. Every book I have recommends keeping it cool. I have not found that the cold affects the yeast in any way. In fact, I just checked a new package that is unopened, and it recommends putting it in the fridge after opening.
 
1,403
37
Joined Jan 1, 2001
In storing yeast, moisture is your enemy. If you keep the dried yeast frozen or refirgerated in a sealed and air-tight container, as Jill described, you should have no problems. The freezer is generally a drier environment with a more constant temperature than a refrigerator where the door opens and closes, the temp flucuates and the humidity (again, your enemy) rises and falls with the moisture evaporation of fruits, veggies, juices, soups and the like.

Jill, I have not tried Fermipan. Where do you buy it? I get the SAF from Whole Foods in NJ but they don't always have it.
 
4,450
104
Joined Aug 4, 2000
I've always used SAF Red Instant Yeast with consistently good results. It's stored in the freezer with no apparent harmful effects.

I plan to try the osmotolerant SAF Gold Instant Yeast in the near future, made especially for sweet pastry doughs and sourdoughs.
 
131
10
Joined Mar 12, 2001
I order all my yeast from King Arthur. I can't find the variety here that they have. I have been using the gold instant for my sweet breads and have been very pleased with the quality. Right now I keep three kinds in the freezer, right in front of the spare spices from Penzeys....just don't tell the family.;)
 
137
11
Joined Mar 7, 2001
I use SAF red yeast at the bakery. I go through a case so fast though I don't bother freezing it. I like the way that it works...no pre ferment just mix it all up. It is great.
 
94
10
Joined Mar 22, 2002
Me too, on the SAF instant - no mess, no proofing, very reliable. I keep it in the freezer. I bought some Red Star Instant Yeast from King Arthur, and like it - but it's been discontinued. Does anyone think there's any noticeable flavor difference in yeasts? I can't - but maybe that's me.

For the serious bread bakers out there - have you seen the website The Artisan?

http://home.earthlink.net/~ggda/TheArtisanMain.htm

very complex to navigate, but the stuff they have - more than you'll ever need to know about how yeast works, and like a chart of equivalences for cake, dry and instant yeast, as well as percentages:

http://www.theartisan.net/The_Artisa...t%20Conversion
 
1
10
Joined Jul 29, 2014
I use both SAF Insta and Fermipan depending on the type of results I need to get. For a no time dough I use the Insta, for an over nite rest and bake use Fermipan as it gives you a better flavor and ahearty crust plus will handle the acids produced with an over nite rest in the retarder. Having said that, I still prefer Fresh Yeast (Fleshmans),for any and all donuts and pastries as it imparts the rich yeasty flavor people like.
 
Top Bottom